Molecular Pathogenesis
Caveolin-3 is essential for the biogenesis of caveolae, small invaginations of the muscle plasma membrane that play a critical role in the maintenance of muscle cell structural integrity and signaling.
The role of caveolae and caveolin-3 in muscle has become clinically relevant with the finding that pathogenic variants in CAV3 are associated with several muscle pathologies including a rare form of LGMD1C, hereditary rippling muscle disease (RMD), distal myopathy (DM), hyperCKemia (HCK), and hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (HCM). Genotype-phenotype correlations do not exist, as studies have shown that the same pathogenic variant can lead to heterogeneous clinical phenotypes and muscle histopathologic changes [Fulizio et al 2005].
Phenotypic characterization of the first two CAV3 pathogenic variants identified in individuals with LGMD1C (p.Pro104Leu and ΔTFT [deletion of amino acid residues 63-65]) indicated that these mutated variants form unstable high-molecular-mass aggregates that are retained in the Golgi complex and are not correctly targeted to the plasma membrane [Minetti et al 1998, Galbiati et al 1999b]. Consistent with their autosomal dominant inheritance, these pathogenic variants cause retention of wild-type caveolin-3 in the Golgi compartment, thus inducing the proteolysis of wild-type caveolin-3 by ubiquitination and proteasomal degradation [Galbiati et al 1999b, Galbiati et al 2000]. Moreover, Smythe et al [2003] determined that ΔTFT in post-mitotic skeletal myotubes severely reduces the binding of the signal molecule Src to caveolin-3, diminishes targeting of Src to lipid rafts, and causes abnormal perinuclear accumulation of Src. Along with these alterations of Src localization and targeting, Src activation is elevated in myotubes expressing the ΔTFT pathogenic variant, and an increased incidence of apoptosis in those cells compared with control myotubes is observed. These results indicate that CAV3 pathogenic variants, by impairing the formation of caveolae at muscle sarcolemma, disrupt normal cellular signal transduction pathways, alter muscle cell structural integrity, and cause apoptosis.
A similar experimental approach was utilized to complete a functional characterization of the CAV3 pathogenic variant p.Arg26Gln, which was identified in individuals with LGMD1C, RMD, DM, and HCK. The p.Arg26Gln amino acid change decreases the steady-state expression levels of caveolin-3, leads to intracellular retention of the protein in a perinuclear Golgi compartment, and causes caveolin-3 to be partially excluded from lipid rafts/caveolae-enriched membrane domains. However, this pathogenic variant does not behave in a dominant-negative fashion because it does not affect the subcellular localization of wild-type caveolin-3 [Sotgia et al 2003b]. These data provide a likely explanation for the observed differences in detectable levels of the caveolin-3 protein in human muscle tissue biopsies taken from patients with ΔTFT/p.Pro104Leu pathogenic variants (90%-95% reduction in caveolin-3 levels [Minetti et al 1998]) vs. the p.Arg26Gln pathogenic variant (60%-80% reduction in caveolin-3 levels [Cagliani et al 2003]). These differences in the levels and functionality of the remaining wild-type caveolin-3 protein may explain the varied clinical presentations as well.
It is important to note that individuals with LGMD1C and experimental models of p.Pro104Leu and ΔTFT CAV3 pathogenic variants also manifest mislocalization of dysferlin, a muscle membrane protein that is decreased in Miyoshi myopathy and LGMD2B. In physiologic conditions, dysferlin interacts with caveolin-3 on the muscle sarcolemmma, whereas in the presence of caveolin-3 deficiency it accumulates in the cytoplasm or it displays an irregular "patchy" distribution on the membrane [Matsuda et al 2001, Hernández-Deviez et al 2006]. Selcen et al [2001] indicated striking disruptions of the structure of the sarcolemma in muscle biopsy from individuals with Myoshi myopathy, thus suggesting an important role for dysferlin in muscle cell structure. It is possible that changes in dysferlin cellular localization may contribute to the pathogenesis of caveolin-3 associated disorders. The functional relevance and the mechanisms of action of caveolin-3 in skeletal muscle cells has been further demonstrated by the analysis of the consequences of CAV3 inactivation both in vitro and in vivo. Antisense inhibition of caveolin-3 expression in cultured skeletal myoblasts precludes myoblast fusion and myotube formation, normal processes of skeletal muscle development [Galbiati et al 1999a, Volonte et al 2003].
Cav3 knockout mice lack muscle cell caveolae and display a number of myopathic changes consistent with mild muscular dystrophy. Soleus muscle degenerates in the knockout animals by age eight weeks, as does the diaphragm at eight to thirty weeks, but there is otherwise no effect on growth and motor movement relative to wild-type mice. Cav3 +/- hemizygotes have no muscle myopathy, indicating an autosomal recessive transmission of the myopathic phenotype, which contrasts with the dominant-negative Cav3 pathogenic missense variants associated with LGMD1C [Hagiwara et al 2000]. Cav3 -/- mice develop cardiomyopathy characterized by cardiac hypertrophy, dilation, and reduced fractional shortening by age four months. Histologically, the cardiac muscle shows increased cellular infiltration with accompanying perivascular fibrosis [Hnasko & Lisanti 2003].
Benign variants. See Table 2 (pdf) for a list of CAV3 variants reported to have no noticeable phenotypic effect.
Pathogenic variants. To date, 30 single-nucleotide variants and two microdeletions have been described in CAV3. Although the first two pathogenic variants discovered, i.e. p.Pro104Leu and ΔTFT, involve two of the 12 residues conserved among all the members of the caveolin protein family, other pathogenic variants are not in conserved residues [Gazzerro et al 2010].
See Table 3 (pdf) for a list of CAV3 pathogenic variants and associated phenotypes.
Normal gene product. Caveolae are vesicular invaginations of the plasma membrane that regulate vesicular trafficking events and signal transduction processes. Caveolins function as scaffolding proteins to organize specific lipids (cholesterol and glycosphingolipids) and signaling molecules (Src-like kinase, Ha-Ras, nitric oxide synthase, and G proteins) within caveolae membranes.
Caveolin-3 is a muscle-specific membrane protein and the principal component of caveolae membrane in muscle cells in vivo [Tang et al 1996, Way & Parton 1996]. Caveolin-3 contains a 20-amino acid scaffolding domain that is critical for homo-oligomerization and for interaction with several caveolin-associated molecules, and a 33-amino acid hydrophobic domain that spans the cell membrane [Williams & Lisanti 2004]. During the process of caveolae formation, caveolin-3 undergoes two stages of self-association or oligomerization in the endoplasmic reticulum. Each homo-oligomer contains approximately 14-16 caveolin monomers. At a later stage, the caveolin homo-oligomers interact with each other to form clusters that are approximately 25-50 nm in diameter.
The expression of caveolin-3 is induced during the differentiation of skeletal myoblast, and caveolin-3 displays several functions in muscle cells. On the muscle sarcolemma it forms a complex with dystrophin and its associated glycoproteins, thus contributing to the structural stability of the plasma membrane [Song et al 1996]. A direct interaction between β-dystroglycan and caveolin-3 has been demonstrated [Sotgia et al 2000]. However, under certain conditions caveolin-3 can be physically separated from the dystrophin complex [Crosbie et al 1998]. This indicates that although caveolin-3 is dystrophin associated, it is not absolutely required for the biogenesis of the dystrophin complex. Electron microscopy studies have demonstrated a transient association of caveolin-3 with transverse tubules (T tubules) during differentiation of mouse skeletal fibers. Moreover, on the plasma membrane caveolin-3 interacts with nitric oxide synthase, a molecule that is important for the regulation of muscle contractility and exercise-induced glucose uptake [García-Cardeña et al 1997, Williams & Lisanti 2004].
In addition to its structural functions, caveolin-3 is required for the insulin receptor-mediated activation of glucose uptake and it regulates the subcellular distribution of phosphofructokinase (PFK), a key enzyme of carbohydrate metabolism [Sotgia et al 2003a, Fecchi et al 2006]. These data indicate that caveolae play a critical role also in the control of energy metabolism of skeletal muscle fibers.
Abnormal gene product. Most CAV3 pathogenic variants result in a severe reduction of the caveolin-3 protein in muscle and a loss of caveolae at the sarcolemma.
Functional studies utilizing overexpression of p.Pro104Leu, ΔTFT, and p.Arg26Gln pathogenic variants in a heterologous cell system (NIH3T3) have indicated that these mutated forms of caveolin-3 display an impaired homo-oligomerization, are retained within the Golgi complex, and do not localize at the plasma membrane. In addition, misfolded caveolin-3 oligomers are targeted to proteasomal degradation and can exert a dominant-negative effect on wild-type protein [Gazzerro et al 2010].