Clinical Description
The two groups of disorders and the phenotypes comprising autosomal dominant TRPV4 disorders (listed from mildest to most severe) are:
Neuromuscular disorders (see
Table 1):
Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 2C
Scapuloperoneal spinal muscular atrophy
Congenital distal spinal muscular atrophy
Familial digital arthropathy-brachydactyly
Autosomal dominant brachyolmia
Spondylometaphyseal dysplasia, Kozlowski type
Spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia, Maroteaux type
Parastremmatic dysplasia
Metatropic dysplasia
The phenotypic spectra within both neuromuscular and skeletal groups are broad and overlapping, and the phenotypes of both groups can in rare cases overlap as well [Chen et al 2010, Unger et al 2011, Cho et al 2012].
Of note, sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL), which is bilateral and progressive and ranges from mild to moderate, can occur in both phenotypes. Onset is from childhood to adulthood [Kannu et al 2007, Landouré et al 2010].
Neuromuscular Disorders
The autosomal dominant TRPV4 neuromuscular disorders are peripheral neuropathies/neuronopathies in which motor nerves are more prominently affected than sensory nerves [Landouré et al 2010].
Clinical findings and age of onset can be extremely variable in TRPV4 neuromuscular disorders both between and within families [Dyck et al 1994, Donaghy & Kennett 1999, Zimoń et al 2010, Echaniz-Laguna et al 2014]. Affected individuals usually become symptomatic between early childhood and age 25 years; however, disease onset can range from birth, with breathing difficulties and delayed walking, to after the eighth decade [Zimoń et al 2010, Echaniz-Laguna et al 2014]. In some, the manifestations can be so mild as to go unrecognized by the affected individual and physicians.
Affected individuals typically demonstrate progressive weakness and atrophy of distal muscles in the feet and/or hands, usually associated with depressed tendon reflexes and mild or no sensory loss. However, the congenital phenotypes, scapuloperoneal spinal muscular atrophy (SPSMA) and congenital distal spinal muscular atrophy (CDSMA), are characterized by long plateau periods without obvious deterioration [Vlam et al 2012]. Atrophy of the intrinsic hand muscles is common, but tendon reflexes may be intact in the arms. Proximal limb muscles may be involved, particularly in SPSMA. The pattern of muscle involvement in SPSMA includes progressive shoulder girdle atrophy and weakness leading to scapular winging (scapula alata) and involvement of the two muscle groups below the knee (peroneal distribution) [DeLong & Siddique 1992]. Mild sensory deficits of position, vibration, and pain/temperature may occur in the feet or sensation may be intact.
Laryngeal dysfunction is a hallmark of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 2C (CMT2C) and is often observed in individuals with SPSMA and CDSMA [Auer-Grumbach et al 2010, Deng et al 2010, Landouré et al 2010, Zimoń et al 2010, Echaniz-Laguna et al 2014]. The typical presenting symptoms are difficulty with phonation and breathing (inspiratory stridor and hoarseness) and distal leg weakness and atrophy.
Individuals with severe features may have a decreased life span secondary to respiratory complications [Santoro et al 2002, McEntagart et al 2005].
Skeletal Dysplasias
Familial digital arthropathy-brachydactyly is not evident at birth because the hands and feet and skeletal examination (including radiographs) are normal. In early childhood relative shortening of the middle and distal phalanges and swelling and decreased range of motion of the interphalangeal joints become apparent. Later, in the first decade and beyond, the other joints of the hands and feet become painful and deformed. No overlap is currently recognized with the manifestations of the other autosomal dominant TRPV4 skeletal dysplasias.
The remaining autosomal dominant TRPV4 skeletal disorders are characterized by varying degrees of disproportionate short stature and progressive spinal deformity with scoliosis with or without kyphosis.
Autosomal dominant brachyolmia is the mildest of the short stature TRPV4 skeletal conditions. Its name derives from the Greek roots brachy-, meaning "short," and -olmos, meaning "trunk" or "shoulder." Affected individuals have only mild short stature and the limbs are typically unaffected; thus, physical function is unaffected.
Spondylometaphyseal dysplasia, Kozlowski type is characterized by short-trunk short stature, although the chest is broader than in some of the more severe autosomal dominant TRPV4 skeletal dysplasias. Birth length is average. Affected children usually come to medical attention in early childhood when poor growth with disproportionate stature and a waddling gait with genu varum become evident. Premature osteoarthritis of the joints is common.
Spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia, Maroteaux type is characterized by short-trunk dwarfism and brachydactyly. Birth length is usually average. Poor growth with a short trunk and overall short stature become evident in childhood. Over time, genu valgum and kyphoscoliosis develop. Osteoporosis has been described.
Parastremmatic dysplasia, probably the rarest of the autosomal dominant TRPV4 skeletal dysplasias, is characterized by severe limb deformities and joint malalignment, short stature, and kyphoscoliosis, which are present at birth and progressively worsen throughout life.
Metatropic dysplasia (from the Greek metatropos, meaning "with change/changing pattern") was named after the striking reversal of body proportions between birth and childhood. At birth, the limbs are disproportionately short (due to the long bone metaphyseal abnormalities) compared to the trunk. In childhood, when the platyspondyly and scoliosis and/or kyphosis become more severe, the trunk becomes relatively short compared to the limbs.
Metatropic dysplasia may be lethal in the prenatal or perinatal period, largely due to an extremely narrow chest and hypoplastic lung parenchyma. Infants who survive the perinatal period typically develop severe kyphoscoliosis that eventually compromises pulmonary function. Other skeletal findings in some individuals with severe metatropic dysplasia are poor joint range of motion, joint contractures, and torticollis; these arthrogryposis multiplex congenita-like contractures represent an overlap between the neuromuscular and skeletal phenotypes of autosomal dominant TRPV4 disorders [Unger et al 2011].
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
In general, specific sets of TRPV4 pathogenic variants have been associated with either neuromuscular disorders or skeletal dysplasia; overlap may occur, however, making genotype-phenotype correlations difficult (see Molecular Genetics) [Unger et al 2011, Sullivan & Earley 2013].
Functional studies suggest that TRPV4 pathogenic variants associated with neuromuscular disorders and skeletal dysplasias may cause a gain-of-channel function [Rock et al 2008, Krakow et al 2009, Nilius & Voets 2013, Sullivan et al 2015], whereas the pathogenic variants associated with familial digital arthropathy-brachydactyly (FDAB) may cause a loss-of-channel function.
TRPV4 neuromuscular disorders. Several studies suggest that most TRPV4 pathogenic variants associated with a neuromuscular phenotype cluster on the highly positively charged convex surface of the ankyrin repeats domain and target arginine residues that are strictly conserved throughout 27 available TRPV4 orthologs [Auer-Grumbach et al 2010, Deng et al 2010, Landouré et al 2010, Sullivan et al 2015]. These surface pathogenic variants are located in three consecutive finger loops of the protein, a distinct region of the TRPV4 ankyrin repeats. The most commonly reported and best validated pathogenic TRPV4 variants are the following: p.Arg186Gln, p.Arg232Cys, p.Arg269Cys, p.Arg269His, p.Arg315Trp, p.Arg316Cys, and p.Arg316His [Auer-Grumbach et al 2010, Deng et al 2010, Landouré et al 2010, Klein et al 2011, Landouré et al 2012]. Variable phenotypes have been reported, even among members of the same family [Landouré et al 2010].
TRPV4 skeletal dysplasias. In total, more than 50 pathogenic variants in TRPV4 have been reported to cause brachyolmias. While the pathogenic variants are spread throughout the gene, two hot spots have been observed at residues Pro799 in exon 15 and Arg594 in exon 11 [Nishimura et al 2012], which localize to the channel pore region.
The familial digital arthropathy-brachydactyly-causing pathogenic variants are restricted to finger 3 of the ankyrin repeats domain (pathogenic variants p.Gly270Val, p.Arg271Pro, p.Phe273Leu) [Nilius & Voets 2013].
Overlap of TRPV4 neuromuscular disorders and skeletal dysplasias. Of note, the pathogenic variants p.Ala217Ser, p.Glu278Lys, p.Arg269Cys, p.Arg315Trp, p.Tyr591Cys, p.Arg594His, p.Val620Ile, p.Glu797Lys, and p.Pro799Arg have been associated with both neuromuscular disease and skeletal dysplasia [Zimoń et al 2010, Cho et al 2012, Faye et al 2019]. In addition, the pathogenic variant p.Ser542Tyr caused both CMT2C and short stature in one family [Chen et al 2010].
Prevalence
The prevalence of the autosomal dominant TRPV4 neuromuscular and skeletal dysplasias has not been well studied.
Fawcett et al [2012] determined that 13 (<1%) of 422 individuals with a CMT2 (axonal CMT) phenotype were heterozygous for a TRPV4 pathogenic variant. Of note, the detection of a TRPV4 pathogenic variant increased to between 9% and 16% in those with a CMT2 phenotype with additional unusual features (e.g., vocal fold weakness, diaphragmatic paresis, skeletal dysplasia) [Fawcett et al 2012, Echaniz-Laguna et al 2014].