Clinical Description
Serine deficiency disorders include a spectrum of disease ranging from lethal prenatal-onset Neu-Laxova syndrome to adult-onset serine deficiency characterized by progressive polyneuropathy. Several clinical phenotypes can be identified: prenatal onset, infantile onset, juvenile onset, and adult onset. To date, more than 50 individuals have been identified with biallelic pathogenic variants in PHGDH, PSAT1, or PSPH [Acuna-Hidalgo et al 2014, Shaheen et al 2014, Brassier et al 2016, El-Hattab et al 2016, Abdelfattah et al 2020, Debs et al 2021, Serrano Olave et al 2022, Shen et al 2022, Fu et al 2023]. The majority of individuals reported have the infantile-onset phenotype. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports.
Neu-Laxova Syndrome (Prenatal Onset)
Neu-Laxova syndrome is characterized by severe intrauterine growth deficiency, decreased or absent fetal movements, microcephaly, congenital bilateral cataracts, and ichthyosis [Acuna-Hidalgo et al 2014]. Characteristic dysmorphic features include sloping forehead [Abdelfattah et al 2020], hypertelorism [Acuna-Hidalgo et al 2014], proptosis or short palpebral fissures with absent or abnormal eyelids, edematous and low-set or malformed ears, depressed nasal ridge or flat/abnormal nose, fixed narrow mouth with edematous lips, micrognathia, cleft palate, and short neck. Limbs are short with flexion contractures and edematous hands and feet obscuring the digits. Rocker-bottom feet have also been described [Acuna-Hidalgo et al 2014]. The skin is thin, transparent, and tight, with scaling or collodion-like ichthyosis and subcutaneous edema [Acuna-Hidalgo et al 2014]. Additional reported anomalies include neural tube defects and genitourinary anomalies. Many infants with Neu-Laxova syndrome are stillborn. The remainder succumb to the disorder shortly after birth, but survival until age two months has been described [Shaheen et al 2014, El-Hattab et al 2016].
Infantile-Onset Serine Deficiency
Seizures start in the first weeks or months of life in all individuals. In about one third of individuals, seizures start as infantile spasms syndrome (previously termed West syndrome); in the remaining infants, various types of seizures are observed (e.g., myoclonic, tonic-clonic, gelastic, tonic, atonic). In individuals presenting with infantile spasms syndrome, EEGs show hypsarrhythmia, but in others there is multifocal seizure activity evolving into Lennox-Gasteaux syndrome [van der Crabben et al 2013].
Seizures are refractory to anti-seizure medications in almost all individuals. Some individuals have up to 60-70 clinically evident tonic-clonic seizures a day. In all individuals, seizures significantly improve upon treatment with L-serine; many become seizure free, decreasing the need for chronic anti-seizure medications. Improvement in EEG abnormalities may not occur until after six months of L-serine treatment [Authors, personal observations].
Microcephaly is congenital in 68% of individuals with the infantile-onset subtype. In others, microcephaly becomes evident in the first few months of life; postnatal microcephaly is reported in 95% of individuals with infantile onset. Those with infantile spasms syndrome have arrest of head growth.
Developmental delay. Prior to the availability of L-serine treatment, most individuals with a serine deficiency disorder presented with the infantile-onset phenotype initially as a hypotonic infant in the first months of life evolving into hypertonic, irritable infants. Individuals diagnosed after the first months of life and certainly after age six months had severe developmental delay and poor developmental outcomes. Development usually plateaus in the first year, and affected children have a developmental age of approximately one year. Seizures and treatment with anti-seizure medications often result in a loss of minimally acquired developmental milestones.
Individuals treated with L-serine prenatally or immediately after birth have normal developmental outcomes [de Koning et al 2004, Hart et al 2007]. Those treated with L-serine at age four months or later have severe developmental delay, functioning at a preschool level in adulthood. Apparently, early treatment is required to prevent irreversible damage to the central nervous system.
Intellectual disability. Delayed treatment with L-serine results in severe intellectual disability. However, results of formal cognitive testing have not been reported in individuals with infantile onset.
Additional neurologic manifestations. Spastic quadriplegia is reported in 63% of individuals.
Growth deficiency. Intrauterine growth deficiency is observed in 16% of affected infants. Postnatal growth deficiency is reported in 42% of infants and is likely due to a combination of factors. Affected infants are irritable, with increased crying and vomiting, and 37% have feeding difficulties due to motor delays and seizures. Anti-seizure medications can further exacerbate feeding difficulties, and many infants require nasogastric or gastrostomy tube feeding to gain weight.
After initiation of L-serine treatment, well-being improves rapidly, with decreased irritability and improved feeding. However, infants that were symptomatic prior to L-serine treatment continue to have severe neurologic symptoms impacting feeding and weight gain.
Nystagmus is reported in 42% of children with infantile-onset serine deficiency. This ophthalmologic finding has not been investigated in detail, and the nature and origin of nystagmus is unknown.
Cataracts. Congenital cataracts are reported in 26% of individuals with infantile onset. The cataracts are bilateral and detected in the first months of life. Additional features of the cataracts have not been documented.
Ichthyosis. Therapy with high-dose oral L-serine and glycine completely resolves the ichthyosis [Shen et al 2022].
Craniofacial features identified in individuals with infantile-onset serine deficiency include elongated face, large ears (becoming apparent in older individuals), upslanted palpebral fissures, and a broad nasal tip [Authors, unpublished data].
Juvenile-Onset Serine Deficiency
Seizures. Individuals with juvenile-onset serine deficiency typically develop seizures at school age. Absence seizures started at age four to nine years in one cohort; seizures were resistant to anti-seizure medication in one individual [Tabatabaie et al 2011]. EEGs showed the typical bilateral synchronous 3-Hz spike-and-wave complexes of absence seizures, which were enhanced after hyperventilation.
Development/cognition. Motor and language skills can be mildly delayed or normal; cognitive function can range from mild intellectual disability to normal cognitive development [Tabatabaie et al 2011, Shen et al 2022].
Behavioral and psychiatric manifestations. Hyperactive behavior, behavioral issues, and mood disturbances have been reported [Tabatabaie et al 2011]. Individuals with normal behavior have also been reported [Shen et al 2022]. Young adults treated with L-serine for many years can develop psychiatric symptoms when L-serine supplements are discontinued [Authors, personal communication].
Additional manifestations. Many individuals develop spastic quadriplegia or tetraplegia and subsequent deformities of the spine and extremities.
Adult-Onset Serine Deficiency
Individuals with adult-onset serine deficiency present with progressive axonal polyneuropathy (resembling Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 2 on EMG).
Some adults were reported to have ataxia [Méneret et al 2012].
In adult-onset serine deficiency, individuals had normal cognitive function to mild cognitive impairment.
Individuals treated with L-serine for many years can develop psychiatric symptoms when L-serine supplements are discontinued [Author, personal communication].
One adult who presented with progressive polyneuropathy and progressive motor disability had surgical treatment for bilateral congenital cataracts at age three months [Méneret et al 2012].
Other
The following have been reported in only a limited number of affected individuals: adducted thumbs, inguinal and umbilical hernias, hypogonadism, megaloblastic anemia, and generalized ichthyosis. These features may be seen in individuals with any of the phenotypes [Authors, personal communication].
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
No clear genotype-phenotype correlations for PHGDH, PSAT1, or PSPH have been identified.
Preliminary conclusions regarding possible genotype-phenotype correlations for PHGDH and PSAT1 can be made, however. Neu-Laxova syndrome is predominantly associated with pathogenic variants located in the substrate-binding domain and nucleotide-binding domain (83%) [Abdelfattah et al 2020], whereas pathogenic variants in the substrate-binding domain have not been reported in individuals with infantile-, juvenile-, or adult-onset serine deficiency. Pathogenic variants in nonlethal phenotypes were primarily located in the regulatory domain (63%). To date, the number of nonsense variants reported is very limited, even in individuals with Neu-Laxova syndrome. The authors are not aware of individuals with biallelic nonsense variants, which may lead to an early lethal phenotype.