Clinical Description
A WT1 disorder is characterized by congenital/infantile- or childhood-onset of a progressive glomerulopathy that does not respond to standard steroid therapy. Additional common findings can include disorders of testicular development (with or without abnormalities of the external genitalia and/or müllerian structures) and Wilms tumor. Less common findings are congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT) and gonadoblastoma (see Table 2). While various combinations of renal and other findings associated with a WT1 pathogenic variant have in the past been designated as certain syndromes, those combinations are now recognized to be part of a phenotypic continuum and their designations are no longer clinically helpful (see Nomenclature) [Chernin et al 2010, Lipska et al 2014, Lehnhardt et al 2015, Ahn et al 2017].
Table 2.
WT1 Disorder: Select Clinical Findings
View in own window
Clinical finding | Present in % of WT1 Disorders | Comment |
---|
Glomer-
ulopathy
| Persistent proteinuria | >95% | Renal hallmark of WT1 disorder; degree may vary over time. |
SRNS | 80% | Criteria for diagnosis of SRNS 1 may not be met initially. |
CNS | 15% | Nephrotic syndrome within 1st 3 mos of life |
|
External genitalia
|
Müllerian structures
|
Gonadal findings
|
Disorder of
testicular
development
| 46,XX DSD or CGD | See footnote 2. | Normal female | Bicornus uterus, polypose uterus | Streak gonads, hypertrophic ovaries, or normal ovaries |
46,XY DSD | 63%-79% of 46,XY individuals 3 | Range: microphallus, hypospadias & cryptorchidism, ambiguous, normal-appearing female | Range: absent to normal uterus & fallopian tubes | Range: normal testis, ovotestis, dysgenetic testis, streak gonad |
46,XY CGD | 18%-33% of 46,XY individuals 3 | Normal female | Uterus & fallopian tubes present | Streak gonads or dysgenetic testes |
Wilms tumor
| 38%-43% 3 |
|
CAKUT
| ~11% 3 | Kidney: duplex, horseshoe; malrotation Urinary tract: vesico-urinary reflux, pelviureteric junction stenosis, urinary sinus
|
Gonadoblastoma
| 5% |
|
46,XY CGD = 46,XY complete gonadal dysgenesis; 46,XY DSD = 46,XY disorder of sex development; CAKUT = congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract; CGD = complete gonadal dysgenesis; CNS = congenital nephrotic syndrome; DSD = disorders of sex development; SRNS = steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome
- 1.
Nephrotic syndrome (proteinuria, hypoalbuminemia, edema, and hyperlipidemia) that does not respond to standard steroid therapy
- 2.
- 3.
Progressive Glomerulopathy
Persistent proteinuria is the most common initial finding of the glomerulopathy. While the degree of proteinuria may fluctuate at the onset of renal involvement, it becomes progressively worse over time. The severity of the proteinuria varies among affected individuals, even within the same family. Note that individuals with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) may be anuric, and thus will not have proteinuria.
Steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome (SRNS) – proteinuria, hypoalbuminemia, edema, and hyperlipidemia that does not respond to standard steroid therapy – is the characteristic renal finding. SRNS can precede Wilms tumor by as much as four years, present at the time of Wilms tumor diagnosis, or develop after Wilms tumor (as much as 10 years after completion of the oncology treatment) [Lipska et al 2014, Lehnhardt et al 2015].
SRNS results in irreversible and progressive decline of renal function and inevitably leads to ESRD. Congenital nephrotic syndrome (nephrotic syndrome that presents in the first 3 months of life) is more rapidly progressive, resulting in ESRD within weeks to months [Boyer et al 2021].
Typical findings of the glomerulopathy on renal biopsy are diffuse mesangial sclerosis reported primarily in children younger than age two years and focal segmental glomerulosclerosis in older individuals (usually as either isolated SRNS or SRNS in association with 46,XY complete gonadal dysgenesis). Of note, because the histologic findings do not correlate with the clinical findings and because remarkable histopathologic heterogeneity is observed even among individuals with the same WT1 pathogenic variant [Lipska et al 2014, Lehnhardt et al 2015, Trautmann et al 2017], renal biopsy is no longer considered a first-tier diagnostic measure for patients of any age.
Wilms Tumor
Wilms tumor (nephroblastoma) is one of the most common pediatric malignant solid tumors. The estimated risk to heterozygotes who have an exonic WT1 pathogenic variant of developing Wilms tumor is one tumor per nine years at risk. Calculation of the exact penetrance is hampered because a significant number of individuals with a WT1 pathogenic variant undergo prophylactic nephrectomy at the time of transplantation or placement of a peritoneal dialysis catheter).
The median age at Wilms tumor diagnosis in WT1 disorder is significantly younger (median age 1.3-1.6 years (range 0-4.5 years) compared to Wilms tumor of unknown cause.
Bilateral tumors are more frequent in individuals with a truncating WT1 variant compared to individuals with other variants (>50% vs <15%) [Lipska et al 2014, Lehnhardt et al 2015] (see Genotype-Phenotype Correlations).
The survival rates for individuals with Wilms tumor caused by a WT1 disorder do not differ significantly from those in individuals with Wilms tumor of unknown cause.
Genital Findings
46,XY individuals have a disorder of testicular development that is either a disorder of sex development (DSD) or complete gonadal dysgenesis (CGD) (see Table 2). 46,XY individuals with normal testes, normal male external genitalia, and normal fertility have been reported anecdotally.
46,XX individuals typically have normal ovaries, normal female external genitalia, müllerian structures that are usually normal (however, on occasion bicornuate uterus has been observed), and normal fertility (see Table 2 for details). To date, two instances of 46,XX CGD have been reported [Ahn et al 2017, Roca et al 2019].
Congenital Anomalies of the Kidney and Urinary Tract (CAKUT)
CAKUT are observed in about 10% of individuals with a WT1 disorder. The most common kidney abnormalities are duplex kidney, horseshoe kidney, kidney malrotation. The most commonly reported urinary tract anomalies are vesico-urinary reflux, ureteropelvic junction stenosis, and urogenital sinus (in a 46,XX individual in whom both the urethra and vagina open into a common channel).
Gonadoblastoma
Individuals with 46,XY disorder of testicular development (either 46,XY DSD or 46,XY CGD) are at increased risk for germ cell tumors, particularly gonadoblastoma. The observed incidence is one gonadal tumor per 30 years at risk [Lipska et al 2014].
Because of the lack of long-term follow-up data, exact penetrance and long-term outcome are unknown. The survival rates for gonadoblastoma are excellent; however, if not treated it may result in malignant transformation of germ cells. A few cases of Sertoli tumor or other malignant testicular germ cell tumors have been reported [Kitsiou-Tzeli et al 2012].
Other
Diaphragmatic defect or herniation is a rare finding in WT1 disorder, reported in fewer than ten infants [Denamur et al 2000, Suri et al 2007, Ahn et al 2017].
Post-transplant lymphoproliferative disorder (PTLD) was reported in 7%-17% of individuals with a WT1 disorder following kidney transplantation [Lipska et al 2014, Ahn et al 2017]. In all children undergoing kidney transplantation, the 25-year cumulative incidence of PTLD, adjusted for the competing risk of death, is 3.6% (95% CI 2.7-4.8). Because of small numbers and lack of standardized follow-up data, it is not yet possible to determine if the frequency of PTLD is higher for WT1 disorder than for all other children undergoing renal transplantation.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
Recent developments have allowed delineation of genotype-phenotype correlations for the following subgroups of WT1 variants.
Truncating pathogenic variants (all nonsense, frameshift, or splice-site variants that are not KTS intron variants; see Molecular Genetics) are associated with the following [Lipska et al 2014, Lehnhardt et al 2015]:
Glomerulopathy. Proteinuria is typically diagnosed in the second decade of life in individuals who underwent unilateral or partial nephrectomy for Wilms tumor. The course of SRNS is slower.
Genital anomalies secondary to a 46,XY DSD affect the vast majority of phenotypic males; 46,XY CGD is unlikely.
The risk for bilateral Wilms tumor is the highest (odds ratio = 18.4).
One in five individuals has congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract.
Missense
variants affecting nucleotides coding for amino acid residues in the DNA-binding region in exons 8 and 9 (see Molecular Genetics) are associated with the following [Lipska et al 2014]:
The highest risk for congenital nephrotic syndrome or early-onset rapidly progressive SRNS. By age two and a half years, 50% of affected children have ESRD.
Of 46,XY individuals, approximately 80% had 46,XY DSD and 20% 46,XY CGD [Author, personal observation].
Missense pathogenic variants
in exons 8 and 9 outside the DNA-binding region are associated with an intermediate glomerulopathy phenotype that manifests before age five years and progresses to ESRD by about age ten years [Lipska et al 2014].
Certain donor splice-site pathogenic variants
in intron 9 (see Molecular Genetics) are associated with the following [Chernin et al 2010, Lipska et al 2014, Lehnhardt et al 2015]:
Later-onset and relatively slow progression of glomerulopathy that typically leads to ESRD in adolescence
46,XY CGD in the majority of (but not all) 46,XY individuals and 46,XY DSD in a few individuals
Penetrance
The penetrance of WT1 disorder is high. It is age dependent, reaching about 90% by the end of puberty.
A few asymptomatic parents heterozygous for the same germline WT1 variant in their affected offspring have been reported [Fencl et al 2012, Lipska et al 2014, Kaneko et al 2015, Boyer et al 2017]. The penetrance appears to depend on the sex of the affected parent, with higher penetrance associated with paternal origin of the WT1 variant [Kaneko et al 2015]. However, current data on penetrance are limited because the variable expressivity of WT1 pathogenic variants was not recognized until recently, as the asymptomatic parents of a child with a WT1 pathogenic variant were not routinely tested.
Nomenclature
Frasier syndrome, Denys-Drash syndrome, and Meacham syndrome were originally described as distinct disorders on the basis of clinical findings but are now understood to represent a continuum of features caused by a WT1 heterozygous pathogenic variant. Given the extensive clinical overlap between these clinical diagnoses and molecular characterization of their shared genetic etiology, Frasier syndrome, Denys-Drash syndrome, and Meacham syndrome are no longer useful clinical diagnoses. However, these terms may still be used in the medical literature to refer to the following general phenotypic constellations:
Frasier syndrome. SRNS, 46,XY CGD, and gonadoblastoma
Denys-Drash syndrome. SRNS with diffuse mesangial sclerosis on renal biopsy, Wilms tumor, and 46,XY DSD
Meacham syndrome. Diaphragmatic hernia, pulmonary dysplasia, complex congenital heart defects, and genitourinary abnormalities including ambiguous genitalia and gonadal dysgenesis; in most reports, the condition was lethal early in infancy prior to development of other possible manifestations of
WT1 disorder, such as SRNS or Wilms tumor. So far, none of the reported individuals with a confirmed
WT1 pathogenic variant and a diaphragmatic defect had a complex congenital heart defect. A multigenic cause of this syndrome, with another as-yet-unknown gene responsible for the more severe cardio-pulmonary phenotype, has been suggested [
Suri et al 2007].
Male pseudohermaphroditism. The spectrum of clinical manifestations related to 46,XY disorders of testicular development with a WT1 pathogenic variant was previously referred to using outdated terms such as "male pseudohermaphroditism."