Table 2Characteristics of Included Systematic Reviews

Study citation, country, funding sourceStudy design, last search date and numbers of relevant primary studies includedPopulation characteristicsRelevant intervention(s) and comparator(s)Relevant clinical outcomes, length of follow-up
Meyer et al. (2022)16

UK

Funding source: NR

Study design: SR with MA

Last search date: December 2020

Number of included studies: 4 RCTs

Eligibility criteria: Studies that included patients who received pre-operative iron supplementation undergoing abdominal surgery

Total number of patients included: 312

Sample size (range): 45 to 135

Interventions (dose):
  • IV iron (1,000 mg)
  • IV ferric carboxymaltose (15 mg/kg)
  • IV iron sucrose (600 mg)
Comparators: Placebo or usual care (undefined)
Outcomes:
  • Risk of blood transfusion
  • Death from randomization to post-operative day 30
  • Hemoglobin concentration at administration
Follow-up: NR
Tang et al. (2022)17

China

Funding source: No funding

Study design: SR with MA

Last search date: February 2021

Number of included studies: 7 (2 RCTs and 5 non-randomized studies)

Eligibility criteria: Studies that included patients who received iron supplementation undergoing surgery for colorectal cancer

Total number of patients included: 879

Sample size (range): 45 to 318

Interventions (dose):
  • Pre-operative IV iron sucrose (600 mg)
  • Post-operative IV iron saccharose (100 to 200 mg)
  • Pre-operative IV iron carboxymaltose or iron isomaltoside (1,000 to 2,000 mg)
  • Pre-operative IV iron sucrose (2 doses of 500 mg) or iron isomaltoside (1,000 mg or 20 mg/kg if bodyweight under 50 kg)
Comparators: No treatment; IV placebo; usual care (undefined)
Outcomes:
  • Change in hemoglobin concentration
  • Number of patients needed blood transfusion
  • Iron-related adverse events
Follow-up: NR
Chaudhry et al. (2021)18

US

Funding source: NR

Study design: SR

Last search date: December 2019

Number of included studies: 7 RCTs

Eligibility criteria: Studies that included patients aged 18 years or older who received intra-operative or post-operative iron supplementation for elective TJA surgery

Total number of patients included: 646

Sample size (range): 58 to 122

Interventions (dose):
  • Post-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (700 to 1,000 mg)
  • Intra-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (1,000 mg)
  • Intra-operative IV iron isomaltoside (≤ 20 mg/kg)
Comparators: Oral iron supplementation; placebo; no treatment
Outcomes:
  • Change in hemoglobin levels
  • Rate of post-operative anemia
  • Rate of adverse events
  • Post-operative QoL and functional outcomes
Follow-up: Varied by individual study or was NR
Elhenawy et al. (2021)19

Canada

Funding source: NR

Study design: SR with MA

Last search date: February 2019

Number of included studies: 10 RCTs

Eligibility criteria: Studies that included adult patients who received pre-operative IV iron supplementation for elective surgery

Total number of patients included: 1039

Sample size (range): 56 to 203

Interventions (dose):
  • IV ferric carboxymaltose (1,000 mg)
  • IV iron sucrose (2 doses of 300 mg)
  • IV ferric carboxymaltose (15 mg/kg or up to 1,000 mg)
  • IV iron sucrose (3 doses of 100 mg pre- and post-operative)
  • IV iron (20 mg/kg or up to 1,000 mg)
  • IV iron sucrose (3 doses of 200 mg)
  • IV iron sucrose (100 mg per dose for 4 weeks as needed)
  • IV iron sucrose (200 mg)
Comparators: Placebo; usual care (undefined); oral iron supplementation
Outcomes:
  • Allogeneic blood transfusion exposure
  • Change in hemoglobin levels
  • Ferritin levels
  • Iron-deficiency anemia
  • Adverse events
  • Mortality
  • Infection
  • Hospital length of stay
  • QoL
Follow-up: Varied by study but ranged from hospital discharge to 3 months post-hospital discharge
Jones et al. (2021)20

US

Funding source: Peloton Advantage, LLC funded by American

Regent, Inc.

Study design: SR

Last search date: January 2021

Number of included studies: 10 RCTs

Eligibility criteria: Studies that included adult patients who underwent elective surgery and received IV iron supplementation

Total number of patients included: 1975

Sample size (range): 44 to 481

Interventions (dose):
  • Post-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (700 to 1,000 mg)
  • Pre-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (15 mg) and post-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (0.5 mg per 1 ml blood loss)
  • Post-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (15 mg/kg or maximum 1,000 mg)
  • Pre-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (1,000 mg/week or 2,000 mg during trial)
  • Pre-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (1 to 2 doses of 1,000 mg for patients <50 kg or 500 mg for patients ≥50 kg)
  • Pre-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (maximum 1,000 mg)
Comparators: Placebo; usual care, oral iron supplementation; no treatment
Outcomes:
  • Change in hemoglobin concentration
  • Serum ferritin
  • Proportion of patient who received blood transfusion
  • Adverse events
  • Mortality
  • Hospital length of stay
  • QoL
Follow-up: Varied by individual study or was NR
Moon et al. (2021)21

US

Funding source: No funding

Study design: SR

Last search date: November 2020

Number of included studies: 9 (5 RCTs and 4 non-randomized studies)

Eligibility criteria: Studies that included adult patients who underwent elective abdominal surgery and received pre-operative IV iron supplementation

Total number of patients included: 1817

Sample size (range): 60 to 487

Interventions (dose):
  • IV ferric carboxymaltose (1 dose of 1,000 mg)
  • IV iron sucrose (2 doses of 300 mg)
  • IV ferric carboxymaltose (3 doses of 1,000 mg)
  • Pre-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (1,000 mg) and post-operative IV ferric carboxymaltose (0.5 mg/L blood loss)
  • IV iron sucrose (dose unspecified)
  • IV iron sucrose or ferric carboxymaltose (dose unspecified)
  • IV ferric carboxymaltose (1,000 to 2,000 mg)
  • IV iron sucrose (500 mg) or IV iron isomaltoside (1,000 mg)
Comparators: Placebo; oral iron supplementation; no treatment
Outcomes:
  • Risk of blood transfusion
  • Number of transfusion episodes
  • Change in hemoglobin levels
  • Mortality
Follow-up: Varied by individual study or was NR

IV = intravenous; kg = kilogram; MA = meta-analyses; mg = milligram; ml = milliliter; NR = not reported; QoL = quality of life; RCT = randomized controlled trial; SR = systematic review; TJA = total joint arthroplasty.

Note: This table has not been copy-edited.

From: Intravenous Iron Preparations for Patients Undergoing Elective Surgery: A 2022 Update

Cover of Intravenous Iron Preparations for Patients Undergoing Elective Surgery: A 2022 Update
Intravenous Iron Preparations for Patients Undergoing Elective Surgery: A 2022 Update: Rapid Review [Internet].
Hill S, Severn M; Authors.
Copyright © 2022 Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technologies in Health.

Except where otherwise noted, this work is distributed under the terms of a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International licence (CC BY-NC-ND), a copy of which is available at http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.